|
||
Domesticity, Public Communication and the WWW
|
Does locality matter in the 'Information Age'? What does 'place' mean to the 'connected' person? How do people feel about new media in their homes and what does it mean for the family? The aim of the Dublin based project is to provide a comprehensive and rigorous exploration of the cultural and social dimensions of new media consumption. It is one of the first to explore how people actually think and feel about their use of new internet media in their homes, locality and beyond. Through living and working in a coastal community in Ireland, I have collected a wealth of intriguing and textured ethnographic material from families in their own homes, local institutions and local community and political groups, and this unique and unprecedented case study brings to the fore the manifold complexities associated with the powerful cultural significance and impact of new internet media in a specific region. The research makes some significant observations about the ways in which consumers of new internet media negotiate the private, domestic and public realms and the relationship between the local, national and European, revealing the complex and contradictory roles of the internet in domestic and local life. Moreover, interesting and important generalisations are made about the politics of social change in a specific locale, which both embrace and resist the impact of new internet media. Aims and Objectives The aim of the Dublin based project is to examine the relationship between domestic internet use in the household and participation in public life and this ethnographic research has been carried out in a localised setting: Coastal Town , North County Dublin. Thus, the objectives are:
The research questions are also divided into two sections:
Research Location and Methods The paper is based on ethnographic data and interviews with domestic internet users. The research was carried out between January 2001 and January 2002 in a small coastal town in North County Dublin. Location The research was carried out in 'Coastal Town', which is located 20 miles north of Dublin City on the East coast of Ireland. Coastal Town was originally a fishing village, but has recently grown and now has a mixed population of older families and commuters; Coastal Town currently has a population of 11, 000. Recently, there has been a vast increase in building and construction work, creating new estates and apartments for both commuters and enabling some of the existing Coastal Town population to buy a second house for letting. Coastal Town also has a social housing scheme, run by the council, indicating the mix in social class that currently populates the town. Despite the mixed population, the majority of families in the town consist of a married couple and three children, where the male works full time and the female works part time (Census data, 1998). Methods An ethnographic approach has been adopted in conducting the research and this has involved:
Summary of Findings The findings are arranged into a number of themes, but firstly I outline the ways in which participants tended to use the internet in the household Adoption and 'Use Patterns' in Coastal Town This summary of use patterns is derived from the survey, interview and participant observation material. The survey of a local housing estate revealed:
The in-depth interviews confirmed and complemented the results of the survey and revealed a high proportion of people had adopted the internet and adapted it to meet certain use patterns. The majority of use related to 'everyday use', where participants personalised the internet, constructing it as a technology to supplement the enactment of existing habits and routines, such as planning holidays. Other types of use centred on consumption health and educational material. Some participants used the internet to become further involved in political campaigns and forums, but few people used the internet to look at CT based material. Characteristics of consumption Most use patterns concerning the consumption of content have the following characteristics:
Structured Use The majority of the participants stated that they did not 'surf' the internet. Using a search engine was perceived as too time consuming, as the majority of websites retrieved were considered irrelevant and unreliable. The time consuming nature of surfing was also considered problematic as the activity engaged the phone line for long periods of time and this was perceived as expensive, inconvenient and a disadvantage of having an internet connection. Thus, participants tended to use sites they had an address for such as the BBC or the Irish Times or sites they already had on their favourites list such as 'pigsback.com' or Amazon. Consumption and Production of Personally Relevant Content Many participants used the internet to maintain personal contact with family and friends. This involved (re)-constructing their families, adding a web-based, or electronic, element to their family network. Other personally relevant tasks involved researching and organising travel and holidays and reading online newspapers and weather reports. School and college students also considered the internet to be a valuable resource for home-work and research purposes. Content relating to 'older'/other media The majority of participants were also keen to pursue websites that related to older or other media. For example email was used comment on, and give feedback to, programmes from the broadcast media; and used media simultaneously; participants both consumed web based content while listening to the radio; and it was indicated that while they continued to purchase a newspaper, they would also look at the corresponding website to read 'breaking news' or obtain a more detailed weather forecast. Domesticating the Internet The research has revealed that most participants gave considerable time to organising the household to accommodate the internet For the majority of participants domestic arrangements were considered crucial and conscientious efforts were made to 'domesticate' the technology. When discussing domestic arrangements and the consumption and management of media participants were asked the following questions:
With the body of work relating to the domestication concept (Silverstone et. al 1992, 1996, Silverstone, 1994; Sorenesen, 1996, 2000) and some further discussion of the work (Ling and Thrane, 2001), I suggest that users carefully balance the 'intrusion' of the technology with its domestication or 'organisation'. On the one hand,. ICTs provoke purposeful changes in the household's arrangements, relating to issues such as, spatial and temporal arrangements. Yet, on the other hand, attention is given to managing this disruption and 'organising' the household to accommodate the intrusion of the internet in terms of its function, location, spatial and temporal boundaries, and the relationship with other media in the household. Based on case studies on households with children and those working at home, it is suggested that users both 'accommodate' the intrusion of the technology, while actively 'organising' and domesticating the internet. Not only do the research findings reveal complex dynamics relating to the ways in which the internet is integrated into the household, but it is also suggested that the domestication concept provides a useful vehicle to analyse the way in which the internet impacts on domestic arrangements and the consumption of other media. These issues will be discussed at the EMTEL II conference in April 2003. See also a further discussion in the paper , 'The Bald Guy Just Ate an Orange: Working at Home and the Organisation of the Domestic Internet' Locality Matters In order to assess the relationship between domestic internet use and participation in public forums, participants were asked about the following:
Participants were also asked about:
For this section of the research I have drawn on literature relating to the media and the public sphere, where research carried out by Livingstone and Lunt (1994) where the ambiguous relationship between media based public forums and the potential for democratic communication is recognised and discussed in relation to the 'chat-show'. However, for the purposes of the research I have focused on work specifically relating to the internet and the emergence of the public sphere (see for example, Dahlberg, 1998, 2001). The findings provide support for those of O'Donnell (2001), who, in developing a framework to analyse 'alternative' media on the internet, draws on the Habermasian public sphere. In her study of 'Womenlink': an e-mailing list for women's organisations, O'Donnell makes two main points O'Donnell's work is interesting as she tests out the possibility of online public spheres via an empirical investigation, but overall, she discovered that women's groups fail to make vast use of the internet in their campaigns, and instead rely on newsletters or postal mail-outs. Indeed, O'Donnell argues that the internet, although having the potential was not used by the women to interact with the global women's movement. Indeed, O'Donnell suggests that there is not only difficulties in making links between the local and the global in terms of the connection between women's groups, but also that Womenslink did not perform as the ideal public sphere. Similarly, my research revealed the difficulties in making connections between local and global and the research suggests that face-to-face locality and place continue to matter to participants and were pertinent in defining identities. Admittedly, the internet with its global scope, by nature allows CT residents to make connections beyond the local, but it was also apparent that while the internet had been adopted as a means to engage with global content, face-to-face locality continued to play a dominant role in the construction of and participation in everyday life. Locality and maintaining a sense of place was important to the majority of the participants and it was evident that the materiality of CT had symbolic resonance to participants and the following key points are made:
PowerPoint presentation on the costal rown Blurring Boundaries: Public and Private The research has also revealed other interesting tendencies relating to the consumption of health based content and the production of family based content for personal websites and the way in which this type of internet use blurs the boundaries between public and private, and the way that these categories are perceived. This area requires further research and an some indicative ideas have been presented in the following short introductory paper: 'Transforming the Family: Towards a Shell Institution?' Download a MS Word version of this Document
References Allen, K (2000)The Celtic Tiger: The Myth of Social Partnership in Modern Ireland, Manchester, Manchester University Press Amarach Consulting (2001) ‘Eir-Commerce 2001 – Ireland’s Consumer Internet Economy: Gloom or Boom? Available: www.amarach.com Bakardjieva, M (2001) ‘Becoming a Domestic Internet User’, paper presented at E-Usages Conference, Paris, 2001, pp. 28-38 Becher-Israeli, H (1995) ‘From <Bonehead>TO<cLoNehEAd>: Nicknames, Play and identity on Internet Relay Chat,’ in Journal of Computer Mediated Communication, 1(2),available: http://www.ascusc.org/jcmc/vol1/issue2/becher Beck, U, Giddens, A, Lash, S (1994) Reflexive Modernisation: Politics, Tradition and Aesthetics in Modern Social Order, Ca: Stanford University Press Beck, U, (1994) ‘The Reinvention of Politics: Towards a Theory of Reflexive Modernisation,’ pp. 1-56 Benedikt, M (ed.) (1994) Cyberspace: First Steps,Massachusetts: MIT Press Blumer, J and Kavanagh, D (1999) ‘The Third Age of Political Communication: Influences and Features,’ in Political Communication 16, pp.209-230 Berdayes, L and Berdayes, V (1998) ‘The Information Society in Contemporary Magazine Narrative,’ in Journal of Communication, Spring 1998, pp. 109-123 Boyd-Barrett, O and Newbold, C (1995) Approaches to Media: A Reader, London: Arnold Calhoun, C [ed] (1992) Habermas and the Public Sphere, Massachusetts, MIT Press Cassells, P (2000) ‘Recasting The European Social Model’, In Europe: The Irish Experience O’Donnell, R (Ed) 2000, Institute Of Euoropean Affairs: Dublin, Pp. 69-75 Cassidy, M (2001) ‘Cyberspace Meets Domestic Space: Personal Computers, Women’s work, and gendered Territories of the Family Home, in Critical Studies in Media Communication, 18(1), pp. 44-65 Castells, M (2001) The Internet Galaxy, Oxford: Oxford University Press Coleman, S (1998) ‘BBC radio Ulter’s Talkback Phone-in: Public Feedback in a Divided Public Space,’ in Javnost: The Public, 5(2), pp. 7-19 Corcoran, F (1999) ‘Towards Digital Television In Europe,’ Javnost: The Public, 6(3) , Pp. 67-86 Dahlberg, L (1998) ‘Cyberspace and the Public Sphere: Exploring the Democratic Potential of the Net,’ in Convergence, 4(1), pp. 70-81 Dahlberg, L (2001) ‘The Habermasian Public Sphere Encounters Cyber-Reality,’ in Javnost: The Public, 8(3), pp. 83-96 Dahlgren, P (1995) Televsion and the Public Sphere, London, Sage Danet, J (1998) ‘Text as Mask: Gender, Play and Performance on the Internet, in Jones (ed.) op. Cit. pp. 129-159 Dery, M (ed.) (1995) Flame Wars: The Discourse of Cyberculture Vol.92, no.4 Dery, M (1996) Escape Velocity: Cyberculture at the End of the Century, London: Hodder and Stoughton Dodge, M and Kitchin, R (2001) Mapping Cyberspace, London: Routledge Donath, J.S (1999) ‘Identity and Deception in the Virtual Community,’ in Smith and Kollock (eds.) op. Cit. pp.29-60 Downes, T (1999) ‘ Children’s and parents’ Discourses about Computers in the Home and School,’ in Convergence, 5(4), pp. 104-111 Durkheim, E (1984) The Division of Labour in Society, London: Macmillan Du Val Smith, A (1999) ‘Problems of Conflict Management in Virtual Communities,’ in Smith and Kollock (eds.) op. Cit. pp. 134-167 Eliasoph, N (1998) Avoiding Politics,London: Routledge Fernback, J and Thompson, B (1995) Virtual Communities, Abort, Retry, Failure Available: http://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/soc/csoc/ Fernback, J (1997) ‘The Individual Within the Collective,’ in Jones [ed] Op.Cit. pp. 36-55 - - (1999) ‘There Is a There There: Notes Toward a Definition of Cybercommunity,’ in Jones (ed.) Op. Cit. pp.203-221 Fetveit, A (1999) ‘Reality TV in the Digital Era: A paradox in Visual Culture? In Media, Culture and Society, 21 (6) London: Sage, pp. 787-804 Foster, D (1997) ‘Community and Identity in the Electronic Village’ in Porter, D (ed.) Op. Cit. pp. 23-39 Fraser, N (1992) ‘Re-thinking the Public Sphere: A contribution to the Crituque of Actually Existing Democracy, in Calhoun, C [ed.], op. Cit. pp. 109- 143 Frissen, V (2000) ‘ICTs in the Rush Hour of Life,’ in The Information Society, Taylor and Francis, pp. 65-75 Frissen, V (2001) ‘The Paradox of Individual Commitment: The Implications of the Internet for New Forms of Social Association and Participation,’ paper presented at the CPR Conference, Venice, pp. 411-439 Furht, B, Westwater, R And Ice, J (1999) ‘A New Approach To Radio And TV Broadcasting Over The Internet’, In Jensen, J And Toscan, C [Eds] 1999 Aolborg University Press: Denmark Pp.169-191 Garnham, N (1995) ‘The Media and the Public Sphere,’ in Boyd-Barrett and Newbold, C [eds.], op.cit. pp. 245-252 Giddens, A (1990) The Consequences of Modernity, California: Stanford University Press Giddens, A (1991) Modernity and Self Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age, Cambridge: Polity Giddens, A (1999) Runaway World: How Globalisation is Reshaping Our Lives, London: Profile Books Gillwald, A (1998) ‘Convergence, Regulation and Public Interest,’ in Intermedia 26 (3), pp. 32-37 Gitlin, T (ed.) (1986) Watching Television, New York, Pantheon Grint, K and Woolgar, S (1997) The Machine at Work: Technology, Work and Organisation, Cambridge: Polity Grisold, A and Preston, P (1993) ‘Unpacking The Concept Of Competition In Media Policy Making: The Case Of Austria And Ireland’, Habermas, J (1995) ‘Institutions of the Public Sphere,’ in Boyd-Barrett and Newbold [eds], op.cit. pp. 235-245 Haddon, L (1997) Empirical Research on the Domestic Phone: A Literature Review, CulCom working paper 2 Hakken, (1999) Cyborgs@Cyberspace: An Ethnographer Looks to the Future, New York: Routledge Heim, M (1994) ‘The Erotic Ontology of Cyberspace’ in Benedikt, M (ed.) op.cit. pp. 59-81 -- (1995) ‘The Design of Virtual Reality,’ in Borrows and Featherstone (eds.) op.cit. pp. 65-79 - - (1998) Virtual Realism, New York: Oxford University Press Herman, E and McChesney ‘The Global Media In The Late 1990s’, In The Media Reader: Continuity And Transformation, Mackay, H And O’sullivan, T [Eds.] 1999, London: Sage -Pp.178-211 Hetland, P ( 2001) ‘Internet Narratives in Norwegian Newspapers’, unpublished paper, Eastern Norway Research Institute Hine, C (2000) Virtual Ethnography, London: Sage Holderness, M (1998) ‘Who are the World’s Information Poor?’ in Loader (ed.) pp.35-57 Holmes, D (1997) Virtual Politics: Identity and Community in Cyberspace, London: Sage Hutchby, I (2001) ‘Technologies, Texts and Affordances,’ in New Media and Society, 3(1), London: Sage Jones, S (1995) Cybersociety: Computer Mediated Communication and Community, Thousand Oaks: Sage Jones, S (1997) Virtual Culture: Identity and Communication in Cyberspace Thousand Oaks: Sage Jones, S (1998) Cybersociety 2.0, Revisiting Computer Mediated Communication and Community, Thousand Oaks: Sage Kelly, M.J And O’conner, B [Eds] (1997) Media Audiences In Ireland –, University College Dublin: Dublin Kerr, A (1997) ‘Multi-Media as Content: Networks and the Shaping of Multi-media Developments in Ireland,’ paper presented at the Ireland, Europe and Global Information Society Conference, available: http://www.dcu.ie/communications/iegis/Aphra.htm Kerr, A (2000) ‘Media Diversity and Cultural Identities: The Development of Multimedia Content in Ireland, in New Media and Society, 2(3), pp. 286-312 Kitchen, R (1998) Cyberspace: The World in the Wires, Chichester: Wiley Lash, S (1994) ‘Reflexivity and its Doubles: Structure, Aesthetics, Community’ pp. 110-174 Lenert, E (1998) ‘A Communication Theory Perspective on Telecommunications Policy,’ in Journal of Communication, Autumn 1998, pp. 3-21 Levy, P (1998) Becoming Virtual Lievrouw, L. A and Livingstone, S [eds.] (2002) ‘The Social Shaping and Consequences of ICTs,’ in The Hand Book of New Media, Lievrouw, L and Livingstone, S, London: Sage Ling, R and Thrane, K (2001) ‘It actually separates us a bit, but I think that is an advantage: The Management of Electronic Media in Norwegian Households,’ paper presented at E-Usages Conference, Paris 2001, pp. 148-159 Ling, R (1996) ‘Cyber McCarthyism: Witch Hunts in the Living Room,’ in Electronic Journal of Sociology, available: http://www.sociology.org/content/vol002.001/ling.html Ling, R, Haddon, L and Klamer, L ‘The Understanding and Use of the Internet and the Mobile Telephone among Contemporary Europeans,’ paper presented at E-Usages Conference, Paris, pp. 40-52 Loader, B.D (ed.) (1998) Cyberspace Divide, London, Routledge Mackay, H And O’Sullivan, T [Eds.] (1999), The Media Reader: Continuity And Transformation, London: Sage Marvin, C (1999) ‘When Old Technologies Were New: Implementing The Future’, In Mackay, H And O’sullivan, T [Eds.] (1999), The Media Reader: Continuity And Transformation, London: Sage McLaughlin, L (1993) ‘Feminism, the Public Sphere, Media and Democracy,’ in Media, Culture and Society, 15, pp. 599-620 McLaughlin, L (1995) ‘From Excess to Access: Feminist Political Agency in the Public Sphere,’ in Javnost: The Public, 4, pp. 37-50 McOmber, J (1999) ‘Technological Autonomy and Three Definitions of Technology,’ in Journal of Communication, Summer, 1999, pp. 137-151 Meijer, I, C (1998) Advertising Citizenship: An Essay On The Performative Power Of Consumer Culture, In Media, Culture And Society 20(2) 1998, London: Sage Pp. 237-247 Miller, D and Slater, D (2000) The Internet: An Ethnographic Approach, Oxford: Berg Mitchell, C (1998) ‘Women’s (Community) Radio as a Feminist Public Sphere,’ in Javnost: The Public, 5(2), pp. 72-85 Morley, D (2000) Home Territories: Media, Mobility And Identity, London: Routledge Nolan , P (1997) ‘Screening The Message: A Study Of Community Relations Broadcasting In Northern Ireland’, In Kelly And O’Connor, [Eds] Media Audiences In Ireland, Pp. 107-126 O’Donnell, R (Ed) (2000) Europe: The Irish Experience, Institute Of European Affairs: Dublin O’Donnell, S (2001) ‘Analysing the Internet and the Public Sphere: The Case of Womenslink,’ in Javnost: The Public, 8(1), pp. 39-58 O’Neill, B (2000) ‘Lifting the Veil: The Arts, Broadcasting and Irish Society,’ in Media, Culture and Society, 22, pp. 763-785 O’Siochru, S (1997) ‘The Government’s New Information Society Strategy: But is Inclusion Excluded?,’ paper presented at Ireland, Europe and the Global Information Society O’Sullivan , S (1997) ‘The Ryanline Is Now Open…Talk Radio And The Public Sphere,’ In Kelly And O’Connor, B [Eds], Pp. 167-191 Outhwaite, W (1994) Habermas: A Critical Introduction,Cambridge, Polity Preston, P (1994) ‘The Concepts of Public Sphere in ‘Political Economy of Communications’ Plant, S (1995) ‘The Future Looms: Weaving Women and Cybernetics’ in Featherstone, M and Burrows, R (eds.) op. cit. pp. 45-65 Plant, S (1996) On the Matrix: Cyberfeminist Simulations in Shields, R (ed) op.cit. pp.170-184 Porter, D (1997) Internet Culture, New York, Routledge Preston, P (1997) ‘Beyond the Information Society: Selected Atoms and Bits of a National Strategy in Ireland,’ paper presented at Ireland, Europe and the Global Information Society Conference,available – http://www.dcu.ie/communications/iegis/preston.htm Preston, P (2000) ‘Content is King? Culture, Community and Commerce,’ in New Media and Society, 2(3), pp. 259-267 Rasmussen, T (1999) ‘New Media Change: Sociological Approaches To The Study Of New Media’ In Interactive Television: TV Of The Future Or The Future Of TV, Jensen, J And Toscan, C [Eds] Aolborg University Press: Denmark,, Pp. 149-169 Reid, E (1995) ‘Virtual Worlds: Culture and Imagination,’ in Jones (ed.) op.cit. pp. 164-184 - - (1999) ‘Hierarchy and Power: Social Control in Cyberspace,’ in Smith and Kollock (eds.) op. Cit. pp.107-134 Rheingold, H (1994) The Virtual Community London: Minerva Robins, K and Webster, F (1999) Times and Technoculture,’ London: Routledge Roscoe, T (1999) ‘The Construction of the World Wide Web Audience,’ in Media Culture and Society, 21(5), London: Sage, pp. 637-684 Ryan, L (2000) ‘Strengthening The Irish Identity Through Openness’, In Europe: The Irish Experience O’Donnell, R (Ed) 2000, Institute Of European Affairs: Dublin Pp. 55-68 Ryan, M (1992) ‘Gender and Public Access: Woman’s Politica in Nineteenth Century America,’ in Calhoun, C [ed], op. Cit. pp. 259-289 Samarajiva, R (1997) ‘Living in the Information Society: The Public Network as a Public Space,’ paper presented at Ireland, Europe and the Global Information Society Conference, Roscoe, T (1999) ‘The Construction of the World Wide Web Audience,’in Media Culture and Society, 21(5), London: Sage Schmidtke, O (1998) ‘Berlin in the Net: Prospects for Cyber-democracy from Above and Below,’ in Tsagrousianou et. al(eds.) op. Cit. pp.60-84 Schulz, W (1997) ‘Changes of Mass Media and the Public Sphere,’ in Javnost: The Public 4(2), pp. 57-67 Seidler, V.J ‘Gender, Nature and History,’ in Wood, J (ed.) op. Cit.15-30 Seiter, E (1999) Television And New Media Audiences, Oxford University Press Shah, D, Nojin, K and Holbert, R ‘Connecting and Disconnecting With Civic Life: patterns of Internet Use and the Production of Social Capital,18, London: Taylor and Francis, pp. 141-161 Silverstone, R and Hirsch, E [eds.] (1992) Consuming Technologies: Media and Information in Domestic Spaces, London: Routledge Silverstone, R, Hirsch, E and Morely, D (1992) ‘Information and Communication Technologies and the Moral Economy of the Household,’ in Silverstone, R and Hirsch, E [eds.] pp. 15-32 Silverstone, R (1994) Television And Everyday Life, London: Routledge, Silverstone, R (1999) Why Study The Media, London, Sage Slevin, (2000) The Internet and Society, Cambridge: Polity Sorensen, K (1994) ‘Technology in Use: Two Essays in the Domestication of Artefacts,’ Trondheim: senter for teknologi og Samfunn Sorensen, K, Aune, M and Hatling, M (2000) ‘Against Linearity: On the Cultural Appropriation of Science and Technology,’ pp. 237-257 Smith, R and Bakardjieva, M (2001) ‘The Internet in Everyday Life: Computer networking from the Standpoint of the Domestic User,’ in New Media and Society, 3(1), London: Sage, pp. 67-83 Somerville, R, Perry, E, Horvit, B, Wood-Turely, S and Sanders, K (1998) ‘Spider in the Web: Free Speech Faith vs. parental Fears,’ in Convergence 4(4), pp. 59-75 Standage, T (1998) The Victorian Internet, London: Phoenix Stein, L (1998) ‘Democratic Talk, Access Television and Participatory Political Communication, ‘ in Javnost: The Public 5(2), pp. 21-34 Stewart, J (1999) ‘Interactive TV At Home, in Interactive Television: TV Of The Future Or The Future Of TV, Jensen, J And Toscan, C [Eds] Aolborg University Press: Denmark, Pp.231-261 Trench, B and O’Donnell, S (1997) ‘The Internet and the Expansion of Democratic Practices in Ireland,’ paper presented at Ireland, Europe and The Global Information Society Conference, available, http://www.dcu.ie/communications/iegis/Trench.htm Trench, B ‘New Views of News,’ paper presented at the Digital Landscapes Conference, DIT, Dublin Tsagarousianou, R, Tambini, D and Bryan, C (1998) (eds.) Cyberdemoncracy: Technology, Cities and Civic Networks, London, Routledge Turkle, S (1996) Life on Screen: Identity in the Age of the Internet, London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson Van Dijk, J (1999) The Network Society, London: Sage Watson, N (1997) ‘Why We Argue About Virtual Community,’ in Jones [ed] op.cit. pp. 102-133 Webster, F (1999) ‘What Information Society,’ in The Media Reader: Continuity And Transformation, Mackay, H And O’sullivan, T [Eds.] 1999, London: Sage –Pp. 166-165 Webster, F ‘The Information Society Re-visited,’ pp. 22-33, in Lievrouw, L and Livingstone, S [eds.]; The Handbook of new Media, London: Sage Wickham, J (1997) ‘Where is Ireland in the Global Information Society?’paper presented at Ireland, Europe and the Global Information Society Conference, Dublin, available, http://www.dcu.ie/communications/iegis/Jw-pap.htm Williams, R (1999) ‘Technology And Society’, In The Media Reader: Continuity And Transformation, Mackay, H And O’Sullivan, T [Eds.] 1999, London: Sage Williams, R ‘The Social Shaping of Information and Communication Technologies,’ Winston, B (1998) Media, Technology and Society: A History from the Telegraph to the Internet, London: Routledge Wyatt, R, Katz, E and Joohan, K (2000) ‘bridging the Pheres: Political and personal Conversation in Public and Private Spaces,’ in Journal of Communication, Winter 2000, pp.71-92 Yoshimi, S (1999) ‘Made in Japan: The Cultural Politics of Home Electrification in Postwar Japan,’ in Media, Culture and Society, 21(2), pp. 149-171
|